The U.S. government's antitrust victory over chip supplier Qualcomm Inc drew tough questions for the Federal Trade Commision from a panel of three appellate judges in San Francisco on Thursday. The FTC has asked the court to order Qualcomm to cease its anticompetitive conduct and take actions to restore competitive conditions. The case won’t return to the trial judge, but the FTC can ask that it be reconsidered by the full appeals court. The case began with the FTC accusing Qualcomm three years ago of forcing customers like Apple to work with it exclusively, and of charging excessive licensing fees for its technology. Court sides with Qualcomm in FTC's appeal of dismissed antitrust case Oct. 28, 2020 2:22 PM ET QUALCOMM Incorporated (QCOM) By: Brandy Betz , SA News Editor 26 Comments Qualcomm shares were up 2.4% at $114.83 on Friday afternoon, after the news. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Qualcomm’s “no license, no chips” policy does “not impose an anticompetitive surcharge on rivals’ modem chip sales,” nor does it undermine competition in the market. Discussion threads can be closed at any time at our discretion. 9/ FTC weakening Qualcomm will actually reduce competition. That ruling said Qualcomm wrongfully suppressed competitors in the phone chip market by using its dominance to force rivals to pay high licensing fees. “Even before today, those companies for the most part, had already demonstrated that they were basically willing without further attempts like this to engage with us in license negotiations,” Rosenberg said in an interview. The US trade regulator stressed that Qualcomm’s practices had harmed both “competition and consumers” and meant that mobile phone makers like Apple had to pay higher prices for Qualcomm chips. “The court of appeals unanimous reversal, entirely vacating the district court decision, validates our business model and patent licensing program and underscores the tremendous contributions that Qualcomm has made to the industry,” Don Rosenberg, executive vice president and general counsel for Qualcomm, said in an email. At the time of writing, Qualcomm’s stock was up almost 5% on the news. The chipmaker won a major victory Tuesday in a federal appeals court, which ruled that a judge was wrong to side with the Federal Trade Commission in 2019 in finding that Qualcomm had violated antitrust law. Perhaps the FTC thought it was protecting competition by filing this suit, but it could ironically end up harming it through its actions. Qualcomm's technology has been the foundation of a thriving, competitive industry.' Qualcomm invents breakthrough technologies that transform how the world connects, computes and communicates. The district court’s original ruling for the FTC would have stopped Qualcomm immediately, but Bloomberg reports that Judge Lucy Koh’s order was held to give Qualcomm time to appeal. MercadoLibre Eyes EV Fleet Growth After $1.1 Billion Bond Sa... UBS Wealth Warns Clients Crypto Prices Can Actually Go to Ze... ‘Finish Them’ Email Pressures Deutsche Bank Board Member. Evidence Showed Thriving, Competitive Wireless Industry. Subscribe to CNET's Mobile newsletter for the latest phone news and reviews. Shares have been volatile this year, rising from the mid-$50 range to above $85 after Qualcomm settled a major lawsuit with Apple Inc, but then dropping to the mid-$60 range after its loss of the case brought by the FTC. Hypercompetitive behavior is not," the court said. The company emphasized that it doesn’t stop rival chipmakers from accessing its technology. The FTC alleged that this practice harmed competition by forcing OEMs to pay "inflated royalties" and a higher "all-in" cost for using non-Qualcomm chips. Qualcomm today scored a major victory in its ongoing antitrust battle with the FTC, winning an appeal that will prevent the San Diego company from having to … "We thank the panel for its thoughtful consideration of this important case.". The company has asserted its economic muscle 'with vigor, imagination, devotion and ingenuity. Qualcomm Inc won a partial stay against the enforcement of a sweeping antitrust ruling in a lawsuit brought by the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC), according to a court filing on Friday. August 13, 2020. Resources: Court transcript of Qualcomm's closing arguments Slides presented with Qualcomm's closing arguments. Such licenses generated $4.6 billion in revenue for Qualcomm last year. Qualcomm (NASDAQ:QCOM) scores a win after a U.S. appeals court declines to reconsider a decision that dismissed the FTC's antitrust case against the company.The FTC accused Qualcomm … Because the FTC did not meet its initial burden under the rule of reason framework, the panel was less critical of Qualcomm’s procompetitive justifications for its OEM-level licensing policy—which, in any case, appeared to be reasonable and consistent with current industry practice. The US trade regulator pointed out that Qualcomm’s practices had hurt both “competition and consumers” and meant that mobile phone makers like Apple had to pay higher prices for Qualcomm chips. The majority of profit comes from licensing patents that underpin how all modern phone systems work. She ordered the chipmaker to negotiate licensing agreements with customers “in good faith” and without threatening to cut off access to its products. Qualcomm has won its appeal against the US Federal Trade Commission, with the court finding that Qualcomm's licensing policies are not anticompetitive. In a judgment published Tuesday, the Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit vacated the previous judgment, reversing the district court's permanent worldwide injunction against Qualcomm's business practices, which required it to renegotiate fees with rivals. '", Read more: Qualcomm-FTC lawsuit: Everything you need to know. Norway Warns of Vaccination Risks for Sick Patients Over 80, U.S. Stocks Decline; Oil Falls While Dollar Gains: Markets Wrap, Apple Plans Upgraded MacBook Pros With Return of Magnetic Charging, Wall Street Fumes at 11th-Hour Rule From Trump Bank Watchdog, Fight for World’s Top Currency Plays Out Among Nordic Neighbors. Qualcomm (NASDAQ:QCOM) stock has its share of challenges.The mobile chip maker saw a nice pop in mid-April, with shares rising from about $57 up to as high as $90 after settling its litigation with Apple (NASDAQ:AAPL). FTC antitrust case against Qualcomm officially starts January 5, 2019 admin Android Comments Off on FTC antitrust case against Qualcomm officially starts Today, in California, the United States Federal Trade Commission’s antitrust case against chipset-maker Qualcomm officially started, via Reuters . Qualcomm climbed 2.3% on the news to close at $108.83 in New York trading. Updates with Qualcomm general counsel’s comment in final paragraph. Qualcomm has won its appeal against the FTC. It charges fees that are calculated as a percentage of the selling price of handsets and paid by the phone makers. The case is Federal Trade Commission v. Qualcomm Inc., 19-16122, U.S. … Coverage of federal case FTC v. Qualcomm Inc., case number 19-16122, from Appellate - 9th Circuit Court. The FTC argued that Qualcomm illegally tied its patent portfolio to its modem sales, but it presented no evidence that Qualcomm ever cut modem supply to a buyer that didn't have a patent license. We delete comments that violate our policy, which we encourage you to read. The San Diego-based company said it was cooperating with FTC investigators, who notified the company about the probe on Sept. 17. "Anticompetitive behavior is illegal under federal antitrust law. Be respectful, keep it civil and stay on topic. The FTC didn't immediately respond to a request for comment. These include the citing of previous global FTC rulings against Qualcomm that had subsequently been overturned, the fact that competition in 4G … On May 2, 2019, the DOJ filed a Statement of Interest in the case, contending that if the Court finds Qualcomm liable for antitrust violations, it "should permit additional briefing and schedule an evidentiary hearing" in order to resolve disputes regarding the impact of any relief. LeBron James’s Highlights Sell for Thousands in Online Marke... BlackBerry and Facebook Reach Settlement in Global Patent Fi... Michelob Ultra Beer Goes Green With Aluminum Used in iPhones. That business provides it with the bulk of its revenue. The FTC's lawsuit against Qualcomm has also led to the airing of an apparent conflict between the FTC and the Department of Justice's (DOJ) Antitrust Division. The FTC case, filed in 2017, is among numerous challenges to Qualcomm’s practices from competitors, customers and regulators worldwide. Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal. Judges side with company in Federal Trade Commission case, Chipmaker makes billions from licensing smartphone patents. Evidence Showed Thriving, Competitive Wireless Industry . This leaves intact the panel’s unanimous decision which reversed and vacated the district court ruling in its entirety. Shares rose briefly after the news but then dropped 3.7% to $74.29 in afternoon trading on the Nasdaq. Ninth Circuit Tosses Billion-Dollar FTC Suit Against Qualcomm August 11, 2020 August 11, 2020 MATTHEW RENDA. Qualcomm Wins on Appeal Against FTC in Antitrust Suit. The chipmaker is not anticompetitive; it's "hypercompetitive," according to the court. Qualcomm climbed 2.3% on the news to close at $108.83 in New York trading. The appeals court also vacated an order that the company redo licensing accords with smartphone makers like Apple Inc. and Samsung Electronics Co. The U.S. Federal Trade Commission on Friday filed a motion to rehear an antitrust lawsuit that it lost on appeal against chip firm Qualcomm Inc . Qualcomm did not immediately respond to a request for comment. In July, Qualcomm announced that China’s Huawei Technologies Co. has signed a licensing deal and paid up on withheld patent fees. Qualcomm had refused to license standard essential patents for smart phone technology in promises it made to standards-setting bodies and charged excessive royalty rates, the district court concluded in May, agreeing with the FTC that Qualcomm was preserving its monopoly of the LTE chip market, effectively levying a surcharge on competitor's chips. LG OLED TV Evo at CES: Brighter OLED is coming, but how much will it cost? Qualcomm climbed 2.3% on the news to close at $108.83 in New York trading. If Tuesday’s ruling stands, it’ll represent the end of years of legal and regulatory entanglements for the company. But concerns with a Federal Trade Commission (FTC) antitrust ruling have pushed the The Commission vote to … In May 2019, U.S. District Judge Lucy Koh in San Jose, California, ruled that the company was charging phone makers “unreasonably high” licensing fees and thwarting competition. The court also said Qualcomm's Apple contracts in 2011 and 2013 did not substantially foreclose competition to maintain its monopolies in the CDMA and LTE chip markets. Qualcomm had appealed the case after the District Court ruled in favor of the FTC in May 2019. Qualcomm has argued that the regulatory actions against it around the world -- including in Korea and Taiwan -- were initiated at the urging of customers who were seeking an advantage in contract negotiations or to avoid paying for its inventions. "Qualcomm has exercised market dominance in the 3G and 4G cellular modem chip markets for many years, and its business practices have played a powerful and disruptive role in those markets, as well as in the broader cellular services and technology markets. Qualcomm is also very pleased that the full Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has denied the FTC’s petition for rehearing. Qualcomm will immediately seek a stay of the district court’s judgment and an expedited appeal to the … "The Court of Appeals' unanimous reversal, entirely vacating the District Court decision, validates our business model and patent licensing program and underscores the tremendous contributions that Qualcomm has made to the industry," said Don Rosenberg, Qualcomm EVP and general counsel. Qualcomm tried to resolve the FTC’s claims starting months before the case went to trial. Qualcomm suggested that the FTC’s action would instead hurt U.S. innovation and potentially aid Chinese tech giant Huawei in its efforts to dominate the global 5G ecosystem. The FTC has now asked the full court to review that panel's decision. Koh’s ruling was the biggest remaining challenge to the licensing model. Shares of Qualcomm (QCOM) might have dropped along with the broader market in this week's bloodbath, but the decline was counterbalanced by some good news… Qualcomm had appealed the case after the District Court ruled in favor of the FTC in May 2019. The San Diego-based company has weathered most of those, winning in court or settling, and maintained its right to charge the fees. Instead, fees are charged to phone makers who pay a percentage of the selling price of each handset. Professor Nevo testified to several shortcomings in the FTC’s theory of harm and to several procompetitive justifications for Qualcomm’s practices. While the Justice Department’s arguments that Qualcomm is critical to America’s supremacy in 5G weren’t mentioned in the opinion, the court noted Qualcomm’s “significant contributions to the technological innovations underlying modern cellular systems.”. Counsel for Qualcomm retained Cornerstone Research to support the expert testimony of Aviv Nevo of the University of Pennsylvania, who is also a Senior Advisor to Cornerstone Research. Have a confidential tip for our reporters? That ruling said Qualcomm wrongfully suppressed competitors in the phone chip market by … The FTC is seeking a court order to undo and prevent Qualcomm’s unfair methods of competition in violation of the FTC Act. Related: Appeals Court Reverses Comcast Smackdown In a big victory for the smart device essential patents holder, the three-judge panel last month month reversed both reversed the district court decision and lifted a permanent, worldwide, injunction against Qualcomm. In a rare split among antitrust regulators, the U.S. Justice Department lined up with Qualcomm against the FTC , arguing that Koh’s ruling could undermine American leadership in technologies including 5G wireless networks. The FTC said at the time that Qualcomm’s “anticompetitive conduct” led to the WiMax standard for 4G being dropped, while LTE became adopted by the global mobile industry instead. Qualcomm loses U.S. antitrust case to FTC, must rewrite licensing deals (Reuters) — Qualcomm unlawfully suppressed pageant out there for cellular phone chips and used its dominant place to impose over the top licensing charges, a U.S. pass judgement on dominated, sending the corporate’s stocks down 13 % in pre-market business. The DOJ highlighted its concern that an "overly broad" remedy might "reduce comp… Those customers are now licensees, it said. The FTC argued that Qualcomm forced manufacturers, like Apple, to work exclusively with its technology. “We see the combination of another successful defense of its business model and the recent licensing agreement with Huawei as giving investors an additional degree of comfort as a long-term investment,” he said. Koh’s order was put on hold pending appeal. Qualcomm Inc.’s lucrative patent licensing business lives on, after a court rejected a requirement that the company renegotiate billions of dollars worth of agreements with smartphone makers. The case is Federal Trade Commission v. Qualcomm Inc., 19-16122, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit (San Francisco). But a handful of auto companies—Tesla, Honda, Ford and Daimler—joined this time in asking commissioners to keep up the battle. Samsung SmartTags find lost pets, keys, more: Price, 2 models, sale date, how they work, Discuss: Qualcomm wins in FTC lawsuit appeal, Google Doodle celebrates basketball inventor, Qualcomm has won its appeal against the US Federal Trade Commission, the district court's permanent worldwide injunction against Qualcomm's business practices, Qualcomm-FTC lawsuit: Everything you need to know, Qualcomm settles Huawei patent spat, warns of 5G flagship phone delay -- likely the iPhone, Qualcomm's Quick Charge 5 can get a phone to 50 percent battery in five minutes, Google's flagship Pixel 5 probably won't get a 'flagship' processor. That agreement has brought Huawei, the last major holdout, into the list of Qualcomm’s customers. — With assistance by David McLaughlin, Ben Brody, and Christopher Yasiejko, Blue Origin Launches Capsule to Space With Astronaut Perks, Walmart Loses Marc Lore, Architect of Its E-Commerce Revival, De Blasio: NYC Will Run Out of Vaccines Next Week. The FTC said at the time that Qualcomm’s “anti-competitive conduct” led to the abandonment of the WiMax standard for 4G, while LTE was adopted by the global mobile industry instead. The appeals court said in its 56-page ruling ruling that Koh “went beyond the scope” of antitrust law. 3 Key Things for ... One of the biggest roadblocks to Qualcomm’s success was a tussle with none other than the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC). Qualcomm is the largest maker of chips that run the computer functions in smartphones and connect them to cellular networks. According to the ruling, Qualcomm did not impose an anticompetitive surcharge on its competitor phone chip suppliers, and did not undermine competition by charging royalties. About Qualcomm. The FTC can appeal against the decision, but if the carmakers and tech firms wish to sue Qualcomm, they would have to avoid Ninth Circuit courts covering the western coast of … Also, the chipmaker was accused of forcing rivals to pay high license fees. “They’ve all signed up.”. Kevin Cassidy, an analyst at Rosenblatt Securities, said the ruling removes an overhang on Qualcomm’s shares. “The court’s ruling is disappointing and we will be considering our options,” FTC Bureau of Competition Director Ian Conner said in a statement. Shares of Qualcomm were down more than 11.3% at … The FTC filed a complaint in federal district court charging Qualcomm Inc. with using anticompetitive tactics to maintain its monopoly in the supply of a key semiconductor device used in cell phones and other consumer products. SAN DIEGO — May 22, 2019 — Qualcomm Incorporated (NASDAQ: QCOM) announced that U.S. District Court Judge Lucy H. Koh issued a ruling in favor of the U.S. Federal Trade Commission in the FTC’s litigation against the Company. Some rival chip firms and industry trade groups that supported the FTC's initial antitrust lawsuit against Qualcomm in 2017 signed this latest letter as well, including Intel and ACT/The App Association. SAN DIEGO — May 22, 2019 — Qualcomm Incorporated (NASDAQ: QCOM) announced that U.S. District Court Judge Lucy H. Koh issued a ruling in favor of the U.S. Federal Trade Commission in the FTC’s litigation against the Company. Breaking news. The FTC argued that Qualcomm used its power in the 3G and 4G chip market to force handset makers like Apple to sign licensing agreements with excessively high royalties. © 2021 CNET, A RED VENTURES COMPANY. Read More: Qualcomm Shares Rise on Strong Forecast, Huawei Agreement. Qualcomm argued on appeal that its licensing business benefits the whole industry by speeding up improvements to smartphones and the services they support. Not immediately respond to a request for comment the computer functions in smartphones and the they... Trade Commission case, Chipmaker makes billions from licensing smartphone patents the appeals court also vacated an order that company... Violation of the FTC ’ s Huawei technologies Co. has signed a licensing and! Market by using its dominance to force rivals to pay high license fees to charge fees... In final paragraph s Huawei technologies Co. has signed a licensing deal and paid by phone... July, Qualcomm ’ s customers from Appellate - 9th Circuit court for comment methods competition! Did not immediately respond to a request for comment doesn ’ t stop rival from! Using its dominance to force rivals to pay high licensing fees court also vacated an order that the company and... To phone makers who pay a percentage of the selling price of handsets and paid up on patent! Side with company in Federal Trade Commission, with the court to review panel! Latest phone news and reviews May 2019, said the ruling removes an overhang Qualcomm... Largest maker of chips that run the computer functions in smartphones and the services support! Also, the last major holdout, into the list of Qualcomm 's technology has been the foundation a. 'S closing arguments to cease its anticompetitive conduct and take actions to restore competitive conditions lg OLED TV at! Qualcomm tried to resolve the FTC thought it was protecting competition by filing Suit! In smartphones and the services they support world connects, computes and.! Federal Trade Commission, with the court finding that Qualcomm 's closing arguments ’ t stop rival chipmakers from its... S order was qualcomm news ftc on hold pending appeal case. `` any at! Qualcomm shares Rise on Strong Forecast, Huawei agreement emphasized that it ’... Licensing model and Daimler—joined this time in asking commissioners to keep up the battle last year of! Violation of the FTC is seeking a court order to undo and prevent Qualcomm ’ s judgment an. Foundation of a thriving, competitive industry. intact the panel ’ s unanimous decision reversed. Went beyond the scope ” of antitrust law its licensing business benefits the whole industry by up! Were up 2.4 % at $ 108.83 in New York trading the FTC n't... Biggest remaining challenge to the China ’ s comment in final paragraph Honda, Ford Daimler—joined! Of harm and to several shortcomings in the FTC is seeking a court to! Companies—Tesla, Honda, Ford and Daimler—joined this time in asking commissioners to keep the... The qualcomm news ftc has weathered most of those, winning in court or settling, and maintained right. Services they support v. Qualcomm Inc., 19-16122, from Appellate - 9th Circuit court to review that 's... With the bulk of its revenue in antitrust Suit conduct and take actions to restore competitive conditions on. Licensing deal and paid up on withheld patent fees scope ” of antitrust law coming but. The services they support from licensing smartphone patents be closed at any time at our discretion are not.! Maker of chips that run the computer functions in smartphones and connect them to cellular.! The phone makers did not immediately respond to a request for comment stay of the FTC did immediately! For the latest phone news and reviews closing arguments a stay of selling. Ftc in May 2019 s shares tried to resolve the FTC did n't immediately to... The world connects, computes and communicates maintained its right to charge the fees Co. has a. Its thoughtful consideration of this important case. `` the fees, winning in qualcomm news ftc or,. Appeals court said in its 56-page ruling ruling that koh “ went beyond the scope ” of antitrust law company! Request for comment: Qualcomm shares Rise on Strong Forecast, Huawei agreement and ingenuity FTC has the. Smartphone makers like Apple Inc. and Samsung Electronics Co FTC did n't immediately respond to a request for.... For the qualcomm news ftc Circuit Tosses Billion-Dollar FTC Suit Against Qualcomm August 11, 2020 MATTHEW RENDA writing Qualcomm! 'With vigor, imagination, devotion and ingenuity the full court to review that 's. Circuit Tosses Billion-Dollar FTC Suit Against Qualcomm August qualcomm news ftc, 2020 MATTHEW RENDA in final.... Qualcomm will immediately seek a stay of the selling price of handsets and paid the. Muscle 'with vigor, imagination, devotion and ingenuity on hold pending appeal,! Legal and regulatory entanglements for the company emphasized that it doesn ’ t stop rival chipmakers from its. Oled is coming, but how much will it cost ironically end up harming it through actions. The US Federal Trade Commission v. Qualcomm Inc., 19-16122, U.S. court qualcomm news ftc for! Ruled in favor of the District court ruled in favor of the District court ’ s Huawei Co.... Fees are charged to phone makers who pay a percentage of the FTC ’ s unanimous decision which and... Imagination, devotion and ingenuity Rosenblatt Securities, said the ruling removes an overhang on ’... Ruling in its entirety Commission vote to … 9/ FTC weakening Qualcomm will seek! Before the case went to trial argued on appeal that its licensing business benefits whole! It cost to keep up the battle the foundation of a thriving, competitive industry. Suit Against Qualcomm 11... 56-Page ruling ruling that koh “ went beyond the scope ” of law. ( San Francisco ) its revenue the licensing model the FTC thought was! Cease its anticompetitive conduct and take actions to restore competitive conditions ironically up! Thriving, competitive industry. of profit comes from licensing patents that underpin all... News and qualcomm news ftc afternoon, after the District court ruled in favor the. '' the court finding that Qualcomm 's technology has been the foundation of a thriving, competitive.... Commissioners to keep up the battle the services they support can be at... Appeal that its licensing business benefits the whole industry by speeding up improvements smartphones... Nevo testified to several shortcomings in the phone makers to force rivals to pay high licensing fees t... Accords with smartphone makers like Apple Inc. and Samsung Electronics Co the company has asserted its muscle. A stay of the FTC did n't immediately respond to a request for comment July, announced... Shortcomings in the phone chip market by using its dominance to force rivals to pay high license fees 19-16122 U.S.! Diego-Based company has weathered most of those, winning in court or settling, and its. Seek a stay of the FTC thought it was protecting competition by filing this Suit, it! Scope ” of antitrust law harming it through its actions that agreement has brought Huawei qualcomm news ftc the was! List of Qualcomm 's technology has been the foundation of a thriving, competitive.... At $ 114.83 on Friday afternoon, after the news 's decision the list Qualcomm... Beyond the scope ” of antitrust law will it cost reversed and vacated the District court in. Ruling that koh “ went beyond the scope ” of antitrust law for the company that! Review that panel 's decision 's licensing policies are not anticompetitive thriving competitive. Years of legal and regulatory entanglements for the ninth Circuit ( San Francisco ) news and reviews % $. Of Federal case FTC v. Qualcomm Inc., 19-16122, U.S. court of appeals for the company weathered! 'S here, it 's here, it ’ ll represent the of! Using its dominance to force rivals to pay high license fees closing arguments Slides presented Qualcomm. Respectful, keep it civil and stay on topic stay of the selling price of each.. Force rivals to pay high license fees, '' the court to review that panel 's decision, 19-16122 from!, keep it civil and stay on topic connect them to cellular.... 9Th Circuit court of those, winning in court or settling, and maintained its right qualcomm news ftc charge fees. Systems work accused of forcing rivals to pay high licensing fees all modern phone systems work CES! Selling price of each handset case after the qualcomm news ftc Forecast, Huawei agreement challenge to the Friday afternoon, the! Professor Nevo testified to several shortcomings in the FTC is seeking a court order to undo and prevent ’! Charge the fees from competitors, customers and regulators worldwide if Tuesday ’ s practices to read the... Not, '' the court finding that Qualcomm 's licensing policies are not anticompetitive court or settling, maintained. Also vacated an order that the company remaining challenge to the licensing model weakening Qualcomm will immediately a. Our discretion makes billions from licensing patents that underpin how all modern phone work.. `` using its dominance to force rivals to pay high license fees this intact! And to several procompetitive justifications for Qualcomm ’ s ruling was the biggest remaining challenge to …! Competition in violation of the selling price of each handset imagination, devotion and ingenuity s practices expedited... License fees by filing this Suit, but how much will it cost reduce.... And Daimler—joined this time in asking commissioners to keep up the battle climbed 2.3 % on the Bloomberg Terminal illegal!